Litigating Wrongful Death Claims in Wildfire Cases

Emily Lou Steenwyk

March 27, 2025

 

Wrongful death claims arising from wildfires involve a unique intersection of tort law, fire science, and utility or government liability. For trial lawyers and insurance litigators, these cases present complex legal hurdles—requiring a clear demonstration of negligence, causation, and damages amid high public scrutiny.

These claims often depend on evidence that is time-sensitive and technically challenging to interpret. That's why early involvement of fire investigators and wrongful death expert witnesses can make or break a case. Understanding how to litigate these cases effectively is crucial for both claimants and insurers navigating liability exposure.


Legal Foundations: What Constitutes Wrongful Death in a Wildfire Case?

To succeed in a wildfire-related wrongful death claim, plaintiffs must show that the fatality was caused by another party’s negligent, reckless, or intentional conduct. The legal theory may arise from negligence, premises liability, product liability, or even inverse condemnation in states like California.

Elements of a wrongful death claim typically include:

  • Duty of Care – The defendant had a legal obligation to act safely or mitigate risk.
  • Breach of Duty – That duty was violated by negligent action or inaction.
  • Causation – The breach directly resulted in the decedent’s death.
  • Recoverable Damages – The plaintiff suffered quantifiable losses.

Who can file?
Eligible claimants usually include spouses, children, parents, or legal representatives of the estate, though rules vary by state.

What’s the time limit?
Most states impose a statute of limitations of 1–3 years from the date of death, with some exceptions in mass tort or government-involved cases.


Proving Liability: How Negligence Leads to Wrongful Death in Wildfires

In wildfire cases, identifying the responsible party is often the biggest hurdle. Plaintiffs must prove not only that a defendant acted negligently—but also that this action (or failure to act) directly caused the death.

Common causes of wildfire liability include:

  • Downed or sparking power lines
  • Failure to clear vegetation or perform routine inspections
  • Delayed or insufficient evacuation orders
  • Negligent utility or contractor operations

Establishing causation may involve:

  • Mapping the fire’s ignition source and progression
  • Demonstrating failure to meet legal safety standards
  • Reconstructing the sequence of events leading to the fatality

This is where retaining a fire investigator expert witness becomes critical—they can analyze scene evidence, electrical components, burn patterns, and vegetation management practices to pinpoint liability.


Role of Expert Witnesses: Strengthening the Case with Technical Expertise

Expert witnesses are vital to connecting technical data to legal standards. Their independent, fact-based testimony often determines whether causation and damages meet the burden of proof.

Key types of expert witnesses in wildfire wrongful death litigation include:

1. Fire Investigator Expert Witness

  • Reconstructs the ignition point and fire spread
  • Identifies code violations, negligence, or equipment failure

2. Forensic Electrical Engineer

  • Evaluates transformer and power line failures
  • Links utility malfunctions to fire ignition

3. Environmental Safety & Land Management Expert

  • Assesses vegetation control, brush clearance, and fire mitigation compliance

4. Evacuation and Emergency Response Expert

  • Reviews emergency planning, warning systems, and evacuation protocols

5. Wrongful Death Damages Expert

  • Calculates loss of earnings, services, companionship, and emotional suffering

Using a coordinated team of experts supports both liability findings and the quantification of damages, enhancing the case's persuasive power.


Common Legal Obstacles: What Makes These Cases So Challenging?

Wildfire wrongful death cases are inherently complex due to the involvement of multiple parties, destroyed evidence, and scientific uncertainty. Litigators should anticipate the following challenges:

1. Multiple Defendants
Utility companies, state agencies, landowners, and third-party contractors may all be involved, creating challenges in apportioning fault.

2. Natural Forces vs. Human Negligence
Drought, wind, and dry conditions complicate causation. Defendants often argue that the fire’s spread was unpreventable.

3. Government Immunities
Sovereign immunity may shield public entities from liability unless a clear statutory exception applies (e.g., failure to maintain public infrastructure).

4. Loss of Physical Evidence
Fires often destroy critical physical evidence, making expert-led reconstructions essential.

5. Causation Disputes
Defense experts may challenge the link between the alleged negligence and the death, requiring plaintiff experts to defend their methodology.


Case Precedents: Major Wildfire Wrongful Death Lawsuits

Examining recent high-profile wildfire litigation helps illustrate how courts approach these cases.

Camp Fire – Paradise, California (2018)

  • 85 deaths attributed to a fire caused by PG&E equipment
  • Over $13 billion paid in claims as part of bankruptcy settlement
  • Fire investigation and utility safety experts played a central role

Lahaina Fire – Maui, Hawaii (2023)

  • 98 fatalities following rapid fire spread into residential zones
  • Lawsuits focus on delayed evacuation alerts and utility negligence
  • Ongoing litigation underscores the role of expert evaluations in warning systems and infrastructure maintenance

These cases show how expert testimony—from ignition cause to evacuation protocols—shapes both liability and settlement outcomes.


Trial Preparation: Litigation Strategies for Attorneys and Insurers

Success in wildfire wrongful death litigation depends on proactive case building, especially where evidence is perishable or liability is shared.

Recommended strategies include:

  • Early Expert Retention – Engage experts pre-litigation to assist with fire cause analysis and damage valuation.
  • Evidence Preservation – Photograph and document the fire scene promptly, before cleanup or alteration.
  • Integrated Expert Collaboration – Use a coordinated team for origin-and-cause, engineering, environmental safety, and economic damages.
  • Assess Comparative Fault – Identify all potential responsible parties and evaluate their role to maximize recovery or defense.
  • Model Jury Communication – Prepare expert witnesses to translate complex science into understandable, jury-friendly testimony.

Why Expert Witness Support Is Essential in Wildfire Fatality Cases

Legal arguments alone aren't enough to win complex wrongful death cases involving fire. The technical nature of fire ignition, spread, evacuation failures, and damage calculations requires independent, defensible expert analysis.

ForensisGroup provides access to pre-screened, trial-ready fire investigator expert witnesses and wrongful death experts with wildfire litigation experience. Our experts offer the deep technical insight and courtroom communication skills necessary to support attorneys through every phase of litigation.


FAQs About Wrongful Death in Wildfire Litigation

1. What qualifies as a wrongful death in a wildfire case?
A wrongful death occurs when a person dies as a result of another party’s negligence, such as a utility company failing to maintain equipment or issue timely warnings.

2. Who can be held liable for wildfire-related deaths?
Potential defendants include power companies, government agencies, contractors, landowners, or any party that failed to prevent a foreseeable fire hazard.

3. Do I need a fire investigator expert witness?
Yes. A certified fire investigator can determine the fire’s origin and cause, and whether negligence played a role—critical for proving liability.

4. How are damages calculated in a wildfire wrongful death claim?
Damages may include lost income, funeral expenses, loss of companionship, and emotional distress, typically calculated by a wrongful death damages expert.

5. Can multiple parties share liability?
Yes. Many wildfire cases involve shared liability among multiple entities. Courts or juries may assign comparative fault percentages based on each party’s role.

6. What’s the deadline to file a wrongful death claim?
Most states require claims to be filed within 1–3 years, but deadlines can vary depending on whether a government agency is involved.


Work with Trusted Expert Witnesses for Wildfire Wrongful Death Litigation

Wildfire wrongful death cases demand specialized knowledge, technical accuracy, and courtroom-ready expertise. Whether representing plaintiffs or defendants, legal teams benefit from partnering with experts who understand the nuances of fire behavior, causation, and economic loss.

ForensisGroup provides access to vetted fire investigator, utility safety, and wrongful death expert witnesses with proven experience in high-stakes wildfire litigation. We support legal professionals at every stage—from early case evaluation to expert testimony at trial.

Contact us today to consult with the right expert for your wildfire fatality case.

Nothing But The Truth
®